Top 5 Car Insurance Companies in All 50 States

If you are looking for top car insurers that will be able to provide consistent services no matter where you live in the U.S. there are a number of choices. In fact there are a dozen or more providers in every state. However, if you want to develop a long term relationship, you are young in your career and not sure where you will end up, geographically; you may want to consider these top 5 auto insurance companies.

Numerous surveys suggest that loyalty isn’t something appreciated in this industry and most people would be better off switching every so often to avoid excessive premiums. So, always keep that in mind. Even if you seem to be happy at the moment it is highly advisable that you shop around a bit and see if you pay a fair amount.

Here is a list of the Top 3 Car Insurance Companies that provide services across the country according to the J.D. Power & Associates 2015 U.S. Auto Insurance Study Overall Customer Satisfaction Index Ranking. Two honorable mentions deserved recognition.

top 5 auto insurance companies

J.D.’s Study

As one of the premier ranking provider across almost every industry, J.D. Power & Associates have made a reputation with consumers for their fair and objective assessments. These studies do not measure overall availability of services such as a comprehensive list of coverage but instead measures consumer satisfaction across multiple metrics.

Their ranking system assigns Circles (like stars) to every carrier based on a 2 to 5 Rating. 5 means it is among the best in the industry, but does not mean it’s perfect. The scoring is out of 1000 and most of the leading car insurance companies score under 900. 4 represent ‘better than most’, 3 ‘About Average’ and 2 ‘The rest’.

This article focuses on national insurers that showed up in all 11 regions of the J.D Study, achieving at least a 2 Circle. In this way, you can be assured that no matter where you go you will not have an interruption with them and their policyholders are pretty pleased with them.

3rd Place is Awarded to Allstate

They achieved an aggregate average of 2.9 across all 11 regions of the US. They provide policies in multiple categories including home, life, vehicle, motorcycle, business, roadside and renters and condo. A 5 Circle was achieved in Florida.

1st Runner Up – GEICO

The infamous marketing by GEICO is well known, “15 minutes could save you 15% or more”, yet it also achieves an impressive 3.4 average. This score represents better than most popularity across every geographic region. A 5 was achieved in New York and Florida.

First Place – State Farm

With an impressive 3.8 Circle average aggregate rating across the country; State Farm wins the customer satisfaction national availability category.

Honorable Mentions

Progressive earned a 2.8 total narrowly losing the third. Others may have been considered but failed to make the cut.

Lastly, USAA deserves a honorable mention because it received a PERFECT 5 in all 11 regions, making it the only insurer to do so by a long shot. For those serving in the military, it is a clear winner.

Although these top 5 vehicle insurance companies deserve initial attention, you may want to consider others based on your own personal situation. For example, a slight imperfection in your driving history may make you less desirable in the eyes of big names but a few others may be able to ignore that point and still offer a good deal. By using our online quotes you can get great rates in minutes.

Share on Pinterest
There are no images.